California Ethnic Studies Curriculum is Legally Inoperative, Grass Roots Memo Points Out

California Assembly Bill 101 (AB101), the bill that aimed to make Ethnic Studies a graduation requirement for California high school students, has sparked controversy since its introduction. Much of the debate surrounding AB101 has focused on concerns about potential antisemitic content within the curriculum. 

However, a new memorandum raises a different yet critical issue: whether the curriculum has been technically “funded,” as required by the statutory language. The Foundation Against Intolerance and Racism (“FAIR”) has released a study outlining the urgency for the California Legislature to provide clarity on whether AB101’s graduation requirement is funded and operative. 

AB101 Is Not Yet Legally Operative

The text of AB101 was amended in Fall 2021, stating that the bill becomes “operative only upon an appropriation of funds by the Legislature for purposes of [the] amendments” that AB101 added to the Education Code. The amendment implies that for AB101 to take effect, the California Legislature must dedicate funds specifically towards the initiatives proposed by AB101.

While the Legislature did indeed appropriate $50 million for Ethnic Studies course offerings in Summer 2021, this action occurred before AB101 was amended and enacted in Fall 2021. This raises the question of whether this pre-amendment funding could or should be counted toward the amended bill’s requirements. If it is not counted, then the “appropriation” condition has not been satisfied, leaving the implementation of AB101 in a legally ambiguous position. AB101’s “appropriation” condition has not been satisfied, bringing its operative status into question.

AB101’s Uncertain Status is Causing Confusion and Waste

The FAIR Memo highlights some areas where the lack of clear guidance on AB101’s status is causing significant concern and potential wasted expenditure.

Firstly, the report brings attention to the financial implications for school districts that have begun their AB101 rollouts. These districts are incurring substantial startup consulting costs – up to $2,500 per hour – with the assumption that AB101 is operative and that they will be reimbursed by the state for these costs. However, if AB101 is not technically operative due to the funding issue, then these school districts face potentially severe financial repercussions.

Additionally, school districts that have not yet begun their Ethnic Studies program planning will need to set aside substantial funds to cover course planning in their June 2024 budgets at the latest. Without clear guidance on AB101’s status, these districts are in a difficult position, unsure whether they will receive state funding for these programs or be required to fund them locally.

The FAIR report also underlines how assumptions about AB101’s operative status have led to premature changes in California law. For instance, in 2022, the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing (CCTC) introduced competency testing waivers for students majoring in Ethnic Studies. This move was made to fill the anticipated demand for new high school Ethnic Studies teachers, a demand presumed due to AB101’s enactment.

Similarly, in 2023, legislators proposed a bill concerning the credentialing of Ethnic Studies teachers. This proposal was based on the assumption that AB101 had created a state-mandated Ethnic Studies graduation requirement. If AB101 is not operative, these changes to teacher credentialing procedures and the proposed legislation are not only premature but could lead to overproduction of credentialed Ethnic Studies teachers without the corresponding demand.

In light of these findings, the FAIR Memo urges the California Legislature to clarify the status of AB101 as soon as possible, and no later than June 2024. The AMCHA Initiative has written a letter that you can read and sign in support of the FAIR initiative by clicking here (scroll to the bottom of the page and click on the blue arrow to sign the AMCHA letter). The current ambiguity surrounding the bill’s operative status is causing significant financial and legislative implications, creating a ripple effect across school districts and the teacher credentialing system. The situation underscores the critical importance of clear, timely communication about legislative changes that have wide-reaching effects on education systems and budgets.

The Case for Keeping AB101 Inoperative

The FAIR study suggests that should the statute indeed be inoperative due to funding complications, it might be wise to maintain this status for the foreseeable future. Several reasons justify this perspective.

Most concerning is the possibility of biased, bigoted, and discriminatory content within Ethnic Studies courses is a serious concern. Versions of Ethnic Studies curricula have been previously rejected by the State of California due to such issues. With no effective measures in place to prevent such content from being taught, these courses’ potential impact on students’ mental health and wellbeing cannot be ignored.

Further, there is an absence of valid and reliable empirical studies that can actually scientifically demonstrate the academic benefits of Ethnic Studies courses. Given the lack of substantial evidence, it might be premature to make Ethnic Studies a mandatory graduation requirement without first understanding its potential impact on students’ academic outcomes.

Additionally, there are currently no California State-approved standards for Ethnic Studies. This contrasts starkly with other courses stipulated by the California Education Code for high school graduation, all of which are based on standards approved by the California State Board of Education. Implementing a graduation requirement without a defined, approved standard could lead to inconsistent course content and outcomes across the state.

Given these financial, academic, and ethical concerns, it seems prudent to keep AB101 inoperative until these issues are adequately addressed. In the meantime, further studies, detailed planning, and constructive dialogue could help shape a more beneficial, feasible, and inclusive Ethnic Studies program in the future.

Sign the AMCHA Initiative letter by clicking here, scroll to the bottom of the page, and click on the blue arrow.

Comments 33
  1. I am extremely impressed together with your writing talents as well as with the structure to your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way stay up the excellent high quality writing, it’s rare to peer a nice blog like this one nowadays!

  2. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

  3. With 1000’s of games, 24/7 help, and regular promotions, this
    new casino has a lot to offer gamers in 2025.

    DragonSlots On Line Casino is welcoming new players
    with a beneficiant multi-part bonus worth over $2000. When you make your first deposit of
    $500 or extra, you’ll get a 225% match bonus as much as
    $2250 plus 200 free spins to make use of on popular on-line slots.
    New players at Ritzo Casino can claim 300 free spins and as
    much as €3000 in bonus money throughout their first 5 deposits.
    The first deposit offers you a 100% match bonus up to €200 together with 70 free spins if you
    enter the code RITZO1. Some of the perks can embody dedicated account help, faster or larger withdrawals, and entry to personal games or tournaments.

    The High Curler bonus of on-line casinos serves to complete and attain an enormous person base, as online casinos should include and embrace individuals of all social
    roots. From the novice participant to the skilled, passing
    by way of the novice who, due to an elevated lifestyle, can guess more significant
    quantities. The high curler is, almost all the time, the highest bonus offered to
    players in virtual casinos. And it is awarded, as already talked about to the massive players, giving considerable benefits to
    the high-level users to outline their VIP participant status.
    Are you an experienced player in on-line gambling as nicely as
    a excessive roller? Then you have to rigorously learn this whole guide on on-line on line casino with
    Excessive Curler bonuses.
    To benefit from these bonuses, gamers usually must
    make a minimal deposit that’s greater than the norm, but the rewards are designed to match
    this stage of play. It’s a method for casinos to indicate
    appreciation for gamers bringing in higher ranges of play from the get-go.
    Somewhat, on-line casinos usually match a certain share
    of deposits for existing players as nicely. Some websites characteristic a dedicated
    deposit casino bonus for live supplier casino games, table games,
    slots, and even sports betting.
    High roller bonuses include time constraints, and players should meet the wagering necessities.

    These intervals can range from 7 to 30 days, depending on the casino’s policy.
    Failing to fulfill the requirements inside this timeframe may
    find yourself in the forfeiture of the bonus and any winnings derived from it.
    Achieving and sustaining VIP standing usually is determined by constant high-stakes play and assembly specific on line
    casino criteria. Benefits of VIP status can embrace
    personalized account management, faster withdrawals, and exclusive event invites.
    Nevertheless, sustaining this standing requires ongoing substantial wagering to
    meet the casino’s thresholds.
    This flexibility permits gamers to determine on the
    fee methodology that best suits their wants and preferences.
    Gamers have the choice to opt-out of bonuses if they prefer to avoid these wagering requirements
    altogether. Selecting casinos with decrease wagering requirements can significantly enhance the potential to
    withdraw winnings. Table video games are a staple for top rollers, providing a
    wide selection of choices corresponding
    to blackjack, baccarat, and poker. FanDuel On Line Casino, for instance, features 10 different blackjack video games, offering ample variety for
    top stakes tables motion. Excessive rollers often favor
    blackjack as a end result of the home edge can be decreased
    to as low as zero.05% with fundamental technique, making it an optimum selection for skilled players.

    Sometimes, before entering the bonus code, you have to head towards the registration form since
    it is the place where you normally must enter it. Casinos supply VIP
    programmes that enable huge spenders to entry distinctive rewards based on their status.
    Kerry Packer, an Australian media mogul, as soon as received round $40 million in a single night time playing Blackjack
    and Baccarat. Recognized for betting up to $250,
    000 per hand, he also tipped over $1 million to on line
    casino workers, cementing his legacy as one of the most legendary high rollers in history.
    Bonuses aren’t just perks—they’re your ticket to maximizing your bankroll and getting
    extra out of each spin or hand.
    Remember to examine trusted Zimpler on line casino for the most effective casinos experiences.

    Place a bet on what quantity reveals up after the croupier spins
    the wheel in one direction with a ball within the other.
    Discover finest high roller bonus casinos 2025 in your nation listed below.
    Casino bonuses are usually legitimate for a particular duration, similar to at some
    point, week, month, or several months. Keeping your Bitcoin safe in 2025 isn’t just about stashing it away—it’s about selecting the best pockets to protect it from hackers,
    scams, and even your own forgetfulness! Whether Or Not you’re
    a newbie looking for one thing simple or a pro who needs top-tier
    safety, we’ve got you coated. From sizzling wallets for quick entry to cold wallets for ultimate protection,
    listed right here are the 9 legit Bitcoin wallets to keep your crypto
    protected and sound this yr.
    Nevertheless, these playing cards can’t be used for withdrawals
    from high stakes casinos. BC.Game’s welcome bundle is tailor-made for high rollers, providing some of the
    most beneficiant crypto deposit matches in the trade.
    New gamers can claim matched bonuses with rising percentages
    and high caps throughout their first four deposits.
    The last bonus tier offers the biggest match,
    making it especially enticing for these depositing larger quantities.
    When our consultants decide a excessive curler casino, payment options are essential.

    You want mainstream options like Visa in addition to e-wallets and direct financial institution transfers.

    For a high-net-worth particular person, bank cards are important too,
    for each withdrawals and deposits.
    Having three is significantly better than one, because
    players can choose totally different types and game sorts
    to higher swimsuit their wants. The $5-$100 wager vary suited my wagering stage, and the game is perfectly laid out to assist newcomers perceive its complexities.
    If you play regularly or like to spend a lot of money briefly durations of time,
    then turning into a excessive roller could be price it.

    However, should you scarcely play at on-line casinos, then changing into a excessive
    roller, and subsequently claiming a high curler bonus most likely is not going to benefit you that a
    lot. In The End, it is up to you to resolve, nevertheless it actually is all down to how a lot you spend and the way often you play.
    Highly unstable slots are a type of game the place wins are not acquired frequently, but when a win does happen,
    it tends to be of appreciable value.

    References:

    blackcoin

  4. It is very recommended to consult with a healthcare professional
    earlier than using BPC-157, especially for people with
    pre-existing medical situations or those taking medicines.
    A healthcare professional can provide customized steerage on the appropriate dosage,
    administration methodology, and potential interactions with other remedies.

    This session can help individuals make knowledgeable decisions about incorporating BPC-157 into
    their overall healthcare regimen. BPC-157’s perform is to
    help with the body’s regenerative process, which aids your
    cells in restoring the body by rising the body’s cellular production cycle.

    These advantages are most evident in accidents that lead to muscle or tendon tears.

    After all, sometimes the best proof is personal experience, particularly when human trials are lacking.
    Now, Huberman is careful to point out he’s only one particular person, an “n of 1” as scientists say.
    However when you’re the one living with persistent ache,
    and suddenly you’re not, that’s exhausting to disregard.
    “I had an L5 compression and I was at all times in pain… two injections of BPC-157… [and the pain] was gone,” Huberman revealed throughout a
    podcast discussion. For somebody who built his profession on rigorous scientific
    analysis, this private experience with BPC-157
    clearly left an impression. Loti Labs makes it simple for researchers with versatile transport and payment
    options.
    It is believed to enhance the body’s pure therapeutic processes, which can be helpful for recovering
    from muscle injuries. BPC-157’s versatility as a possible remedy possibility
    has sparked interest in its therapeutic benefits throughout numerous medical
    situations. One space of interest is musculoskeletal accidents, together
    with muscle and tendon injuries. BPC-157’s capability to speed up tissue restore can especially profit athletes and individuals
    recovering from sports-related accidents, but
    athletes should do their own research before taking BPC-157.

    This systematic method will decide the safety margins
    and allow researchers to adopt responsible dosing regimens as the
    peptide finds its place in both lab and rising clinical purposes.
    As peptide remedy and regenerative drugs advances BPC
    157 will doubtless paved the way, with studies showing it can calm inflammation, repair tissue, and benefit
    intestine well being in animal models. With continued innovation and
    strict scientific research BPC 157 capsules will assist the body’s own therapeutic mechanisms and push
    the boundaries of wellness research in controlled environments.
    Since BPC 157 comes from human gastric juice it matches well with biological methods
    that’s why researchers use it to study muscle growth,
    ligament restore, and tendon restoration. Research show it could also help shield the intestine lining and reduce inflammation hinting it can help keep digestive well being regular in lab
    models. The thought is to leverage the potential therapeutic results of BPC-157 inside a formulation that’s convenient and efficient for the person affected person. Earlier Than diving into the buying guide, it
    is crucial to have a primary understanding of what Bpc 157 is.

    Consult with a knowledgeable healthcare provider, particularly in case you have
    any pre-existing well being circumstances or are taking other drugs.
    BPC-157, quick for Body Protecting Compound 157, is an artificial peptide composed of 15
    amino acids. The applicable dosage and administration of BPC-157 and TB-500 peptides ought to be meticulously
    evaluated, notably in light of the regulatory guidelines established by authorities such as the FDA.
    Analysis signifies that BPC-157 could play a job in decreasing inflammation and oxidative stress
    within the brain, each of that are recognized components that
    may impede cognitive performance.
    Our Premium Lyophilized line is triple-tested for purity, endotoxins, and sterility, and generally consists
    of both double third-party testing and manufacturer HPLC verification. The Standard Lyophilized grade is third-party purity tested and manufacturer
    verified. Our Commonplace (Non-Lyophilized) merchandise are also manufacturer verified and third-party purity tested.
    All merchandise meet a minimal purity of ninety eight.5%, with the vast
    majority exceeding 99%. Each designation displays a selected level of quality control and preparation.
    The key is to individualize dosing based in your objectives, monitor
    your progress, and regulate over time for finest outcomes.
    When it comes to therapeutic the gut, how you are taking BPC-157 matters—more than most individuals understand.
    Selecting the wrong delivery technique can restrict its effectiveness,
    especially in cases the place the digestive system is already damaged or inflamed.
    For instance, individuals thinking about day by day resilience,
    immune stability, or basic upkeep could discover capsules simpler to stick with long term.
    Although anecdotal reviews decide BPC 157 to be a non-toxic peptide with few opposed interactions, additional long-term analysis is required
    for the FDA to concur with such a notion. Under are pattern BPC 157 and TB-500 dosages for researchers who
    need to mix the 2 peptides.
    Cancer has turn out to be one of many leading causes of dying
    globally, affecting hundreds of thousands of individuals yearly.

    In this weblog, we’ll discover what BPC-157 is and the way it might be an important addition to conventional
    most cancers treatments. Scientific trials have proven that BPC 157 might help scale back liver harm caused by sure toxins and
    substances.

    References:

    valley

  5. The second you eat or drink something with energy,
    growth — quick is over. Creatine has been proven to improve muscle energy and endurance,
    which may be particularly helpful for figuring out while intermittent fasting.
    It’s a staple complement for most athletes and bodybuilders, and if you’re looking for severe muscle growth and enhanced work capacity, it should probably be for you, too.
    In both case, you’ll get the most benefit from supplementing with creatine monohydrate — the most effective
    and well-studied type — daily. Conversely, when you’re fasting for spiritual reasons, it’s in all probability finest to devour
    creatine during your eating window. For these doing longer fasts for mobile repair or longevity,
    issues get more nuanced.
    Many health lovers ponder whether it’s finest to take creatine before or
    after their workout. Whereas consuming creatine earlier than your workout might help improve your energy and
    efficiency during exercise, taking it post-workout aids in muscle recovery and replenishes creatine shops.
    So, for max advantages, think about a split-dosing strategy and try taking
    half your creatine dose before your exercise and the other half after.
    For the overwhelming majority of fasting goals—fat loss, insulin control,
    mental readability, muscle retention—creatine is a protected and appropriate complement
    throughout your fasting window. Constructing muscle and maintaining a healthy diet are
    important for many people who wish to stay fit, however there
    are many myths and misconceptions about one of the only ways to do
    that.
    It is unnecessary to take creatine with food whereas fasting; it can be absorbed properly on an empty stomach.
    Creatine monohydrate, which is incessantly consumed
    alone, does not require meals for absorption. People
    could make their own decisions, but taking it without meals corresponds with fasting objectives while guaranteeing creatine uptake.
    There are a selection of completely different fasting protocols which
    are popularly used at present, including intermittent fasting
    (IF), alternate-day fasting (ADF), time-restricted feeding (TRF) and prolonged fasts.
    Relying on the individual’s wants and targets, one protocol could also be higher suited than one other.
    Creatine’s effect on autophagy remains understudied, which means
    we do not have definitive solutions yet.
    We have lined this subject in-depth in one other article should you’re involved.
    Moreover, skipping meals for prolonged periods may impression blood sugar ranges, so
    sure supplements may work together differently than when taken with
    food. Some are protected to take on an empty stomach, while others want meals for
    proper absorption. Understanding fasting supplement timing may
    help you get the most advantages without breaking your quick.

    Research show that alternate-day fasting can cut
    back fasting insulin by 52% after 12 months, in comparability with just 14% with common calorie restriction.
    This method helps continued ATP synthesis and muscle recovery when you fast.

    This course of not solely aids in sustaining muscle mass but additionally helps muscle hypertrophy as you proceed to engage in resistance coaching.

    Moreover, creatine promotes water retention in muscle cells, which
    can additional stimulate muscle development through cell volumization and signaling pathways that promote muscle regeneration and growth.

    One of probably the most pronounced benefits of creatine whereas fasting is
    its capacity to hurry up restoration instances. Fasting can stress the physique, notably after intense
    exercise sessions when nutrient availability is low,
    and the body’s recovery processes are in high demand. Creatine plays
    a vital role here by replenishing ATP shops extra efficiently,
    which is important for regeneration and constructing muscle tissues.

    To break your quick, start by eating gentle foods
    and make sure to not overeat. When researching any supplement, like creatine, it may be very important search for unbiased scientific evidence from reliable sources.
    Scientists often do studies involving creatine and different dietary supplements, and the
    outcomes of those studies might help inform the buyer.
    Reputable web sites such because the Mayo Clinic or WebMD typically present correct and
    dependable information about supplements.

    Blogs and vlogs from medical professionals or skilled users could
    be a great useful resource.
    Whereas insulin can improve absorption, creatine remains efficient without carbs, making it suitable even for those managing
    blood sugar or insulin sensitivity. For most people, particularly those practicing time-restricted eating, creatine won’t break your fast—and might truly support your coaching objectives.
    Simply make sure it’s unflavored, additive-free, and not taken throughout extended
    fasts if autophagy is your main aim. For these aiming to maximise the advantages of autophagy during fasting,
    creatine doesn’t interfere with this mobile ‘clean-up’ course of.
    But, it’s crucial to guarantee that the creatine complement accommodates no amino acids,
    which might activate mTOR and disrupt autophagy.
    We don’t really know if consuming collagen protein disrupts autophagy.

    As a rule of thumb, if a complement has a caloric value hooked up to it, it has the potential to interrupt
    your quick. Any supplement with a natural
    or synthetic sweetener will take your physique out of ketosis
    and autophagy, as they trigger insulin release. Six Star
    Pre-Workout Explosion won’t break a fast, but the Aminos + Energy powder will as a end
    result of it has 5g of BCAAs per serving. The BCAAs in this pre-workout will
    increase insulin when you’re in a fasted state, so it’s best to keep away from it whereas fasting.
    But clear, stimulant-based dietary supplements containing fast-friendly amino acids may be taken before training with
    out breaking your fast, in accordance with main health organizations.

    If your fast is for intestine rest or autophagy, keep away from all dietary supplements during fasting until medically necessary or recommended by
    knowledgeable. Importantly, pure creatine doesn’t trigger an insulin spike or any significant digestive response.
    That means, from a fat-burning and metabolic standpoint, creatine is mostly considered fast-safe.
    Fortuitously, creatine itself does not immediately elicit an insulin response that
    might interrupt fasting. But some creatine dietary supplements
    with added sugars or sweeteners might break a fast.
    Intermittent fasting is a well-proven dieting strategy that has plenty of well being advantages.
    Creatine is an incredible supplement that reinforces
    athletic efficiency, muscle progress, and cognitive function.

    References:

    neurotrauma

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Prev
Major Jewish Groups Feud over Woke Antisemitism Video
Jewish Groups Feud over Woke Antisemitism

Major Jewish Groups Feud over Woke Antisemitism Video

In a contentious turn of events, two major US Jewish groups have temporarily

Next
Federation Dividing Jews in America on Israel Judicial Reform

Federation Dividing Jews in America on Israel Judicial Reform

American Jewish organizations, including the Federation and ADL, are increasing